The wind energy industry applauds the President's emphasis on job creation. Under the President's leadership, the Recovery Act saved 40,000 wind jobs. The industry now looks forward to working with the President to put in place the policies—including a national Renewable Electricity Standard—that will create thousands more jobs, including in manufacturing. A Renewable Electricity Standard (RES) with strong, aggressive near-term targets is the best way to provide the certainty needed for businesses to expand domestic wind manufacturing.

I'd like to thank Mr. Smitherman for his very thoughtful article that logically explains why new transmission lines are essential for Texas to continue leading the country in renewable energy development as well in creating green jobs and associated economic development. I would like to respond to several concerns that were expressed in the comments, though:

1. Cheaper electricity - Before proceeding with the CREZ transmission plan, ERCOT performed a detailed analysis of how transmission development and associated wind development would affect consumers in Texas. It found that building the transmission would save consumers $1.7 billion per year by replacing the use of expensive natural gas with wind energy, repaying the $4.9 billion cost of the transmission in 2.9 years.

Bringing new wind energy online is critical to protecting Texas consumers from increases in the price of fossil fuels. Texas currently depends on natural gas to generate 49% of its electricity, and natural gas plants make up 71% of the state's generating capacity. From 1998 to 2006 natural gas prices in the state tripled, causing the price of electricity for the average residential consumer to increase from 7.6 cents/kWh to 12.9 cents/kWh-an increase of $64 monthly, or over $750 per year, for the average household.

2. Need for standby power - While the wind may slow or even stop at one location, over a large area like the state of Texas wind is a much more constant resource. In addition, wind output can be forecast at least a day in advance, giving grid operators plenty of time to bring other power plants online as needed, just as they do when electricity demand suddenly increases because the weather is hotter than forecast and millions of people turn on their air conditioners, or when a large coal or nuclear power plant experiences an outage and must shut down, often without notice. In contrast, wind energy output changes very slowly and can be forecast.

3. Wind turbines become net energy producers within a matter of months - The detailed, third-party verified accounting analysis linked below (here) shows that wind turbines produce enough power within the first several months of operation to more than make up for the energy that was used to produce them. Since a modern wind turbine will remain operational for decades, the energy and carbon dioxide savings produced over its lifetime are quite significant. In addition, around 98% of the land in a wind plant can continue serving as crop/rangeland, since the actual footprint of the wind turbines is very small.


Michael Goggin
American Wind Energy Association

While the Panhandle has some of the best wind resources in North America, there aren't enough power lines to support meaningful wind development. Therefore, it's time to build the transmission lines needed to deliver this clean, Texas- based energy source to the rest of our growing state and continue to lower electricity prices in the process. And we must do it in a way that respects private property rights and maintains the natural beauty of the Texas Panhandle.