The AWEA Blog: Into the Wind


Dear Mr. Ebert: Don't fall for "Windfall"

As the anti-wind docu-diatribe "Windfall" opened this weekend in Chicago and New York, AWEA extended an unusual invitation to noted film critic Roger Ebert to come visit an actual operating wind farm so he can better judge for himself whether the film tells the truth.

AWEA's letter, from AWEA VP for Public Affairs Peter Kelley, gets right to the heart of the matter: "It was disappointing to see such a normally clear-eyed film critic taken in by such a fact-free and slanted take on wind power."

Viewers may be taken in by Windfall's HD cinematography and lingering landscape views of rural New York landscapes, but there is little pretense of balance ...


Read more

Fact check: “Windfall” Film Offers Greatest Hits of Misinformation

Windfall takes aim at clean, renewable wind energy with misinformation.

As one movie critic said: "The documentary isn’t big on hard data; instead, [Director Laura] Israel allows the majority of her interviewees to deliver anecdotes, speculation, anti-corporate conspiracy theories, and just a few statistics…the movie’s case relies more on emotional appeals and frightening images of giant machines than on real, objective number-crunching…the unbridled scare tactics cast too big a shadow over the agit-prop doc Israel ended up making." (Noel Murray, AV Club, Feb. 2, 2012)

The following facts set the record straight on the issues that Windfall raises:

Health:  


Read more

Fact Check: Milloy misses mark on bipartisan support for PTC

Steve Milloy's recent Washington Times piece on the national energy policy issues currently before Congress tries to paint wind power as something Republicans don’t care about. Here are several of the points he missed:


The wind industry creates tens of thousands of American jobs

 

Mr. Milloy cites “vital wind-industry tax credits” that are soon to expire (namely the federal Production Tax Credit — PTC). He correctly notes that the wind industry is currently 75,000 jobs strong, but that these jobs are at risk if Congress allows the PTC to expire. In addition to the jobs figures that Mr. Milloy includes, the wind industry has also boosted the American industrial sector, expanding to over 400 manufacturing facilities ...


Read more

Republican governors push for PTC extension; Senators express support

Republican governors Terry Branstad of Iowa and Sam Brownback of Kansas provided some very specific support for the federal wind energy Production Tax Credit (PTC) yesterday, urging members of the Congressional conference committee on the payroll tax deduction legislation to include a PTC extension in the bill.  Prospects for a PTC extension were also buoyed by positive comments from several Senators, both regarding the PTC and willingness to consider extending expiring tax provisions, during a hearing Tuesday.

In making their plea, Branstad and Brownback called for an "all-of-the-above" energy policy that promotes a diverse portfolio of domestic ...


Read more

U.S. Chamber of Commerce joins broad range of groups endorsing PTC extension

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce yesterday became the latest group to support extending the federal wind energy Production Tax Credit (PTC), the key incentive that has helped the U.S. wind industry expand dramatically over the last decade.

In a Senate Finance Committee hearing on tax legislation, Caroline L. Harris, the Chamber's Chief Tax Counsel and Director of Tax Policy, testified as follows:

"Inaction on these provisions has real consequences. Businesses need certainty and predictability…

"When Congress fails to act, provisions such as the wind Production Tax Credit… do not operate efficiently. Industries that are in their infancy are ...


Read more

Fact check: Bryce misleads again on land, sound, resource use

Robert Bryce, rehashing previous articles written elsewhere, has a new opinion column in City Journal, the in-house publication of his employer, the Manhattan Institute for Public Policy, a group that receives funding from Exxon Mobil and Koch Industries, a major oil & gas producer.

Mr. Bryce's latest hymn to energy density, like the previous versions, omits some basic facts:

The actual amount of land used by wind power is very small.  The U.S. Department of Energy's 20% Wind Energy by 2030 Technical Report found that if wind power provided 20% of America's electricity, the actual space occupied by wind turbines, related equipment such as electrical substations, and service roads would be ...


Read more

Illinois, Kansas papers join chorus calling for PTC extension

Two local newspapers, in the windy states of Kansas and Illinois, have added their voices to the New York Times and Denver Post in calling for an immediate extension of wind power's key incentive, the federal Production Tax Credit (PTC).

The Garden City (Kans.) Telegram noted yesterday that AWEA's recent wind power market report for the fourth quarter of 2011 shows the Sunflower State leading the nation with more than 1,188 MW of wind farms under construction.

It added, "The ample supply of wind in Kansas — ranked second among windiest states, with Texas first — wasn't the only driving force in new turbines, however, as a federal production tax credit helped fuel those projects ...


Read more

Buffett's utility votes for renewable energy

The electric utility owned by one of America's best-known investors, a man noted for his thoughtful view of investment fundamentals, is planning a systematic organizational push into wind and other renewable forms of energy.

MidAmerican Energy, owned by Warren Buffett (known as the "Sage of Omaha" for his investment prowess), said this week that it will set up a new unregulated subsidiary to invest in wind, solar, geothermal and hydro projects. 


Of particular note were the comments of two senior MidAmerican officials regarding the new subsidiary.  Greg Abel, the utility's chairman, president and CEO, said, "We look forward to ...


Read more

Despite science, wind turbine sound sparks discussion in Wisconsin

The topic of wind turbine sound and human health came up again this week in Wisconsin, with the Green Bay Press Gazette and a few other news outlets carrying stories about turbines in the Glenmore area and a discussion by the Brown County Human Services Committee of their health effects.

Let's briefly review the bidding:

The credible peer-reviewed science, and various government reports in the U.S., Canada, Australia and the U.K. refute the claim that wind farms cause negative health impacts.

Most recently, earlier this month wind energy got a clean bill of health from a panel of independent experts established by the Massachusetts departments of Environmental Protection ...


Read more

WindTV: Mr. Wind goes to Washington

High school teacher and students share how wind power has impacted their town

Last week WindTV brought you the story of how wind power is pumping dollars into the local businesses of Milford, Utah. This week the American Wind Energy Association’s (AWEA) video outlet follows a Milford high school teacher and some of his students to Washington, D.C., where they shared with Members of Congress that very same story, a story they could tell from a firsthand perspective.

Teacher and farmer Andy Swapp, who became interested in wind energy when he noticed good soil blowing into his barn on his farm and ...


Read more